Bihari Boti
Thin beef strips tenderised with raw papaya, marinated in roasted spices, poppy seeds and mustard oil, slow-cooked until soft, then grilled for charred edges. Lovely with paratha or naan.
Ingredients
Equipment: Heavy pot with lid; charcoal grill, griddle pan or oven grill; flat metal skewers; large bowl; small pan for dry roasting; spice grinder or mortar and pestle; instant-read thermometer; small steel bowl (for the optional smoking step)
Method
Trim any thick sinew or silverskin from the beef. For easier slicing, chill the meat in the freezer for 20 minutes first. Slice it across the grain into thin strips about 5 mm thick and 4 cm wide, and place them in a large bowl.
Dry roast the coriander seeds, cumin seeds and poppy seeds in a small pan over low heat for 1 to 2 minutes, until fragrant and just starting to darken. Cool, then grind the coriander coarsely and the cumin and poppy seeds to a fine powder.
Add the grated papaya, ginger-garlic paste, salt and lemon juice to the beef. Massage for 2 minutes, then leave for 15 minutes so the papaya begins to tenderise the meat.
Add the yogurt, mustard oil, chilli powder, ground spices, roasted chickpea powder, garam masala, pepper and crushed fried onions. Mix well so every strip is coated in a thick paste.
Cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, ideally overnight. Do not go beyond 12 hours, or the papaya can make the meat mushy. Keep the raw beef chilled the whole time.
Tip the beef and all of its marinade into a heavy pot and add 250 ml water. Bring to a gentle simmer over medium heat, then cover and cook on low heat for 75 minutes, stirring every 15 minutes and checking there is still some liquid, until the beef is tender when pressed with a fork.
About 25 minutes before the beef finishes cooking, light the charcoal grill and wait about 20 minutes, until the coals are glowing with a light grey ash. Or heat a griddle pan or oven grill to its highest setting just before you need it.
Uncover the pot and cook over medium-high heat for 8 to 10 minutes, stirring often, until the liquid has reduced and the thick masala clings to the strips. Check the beef is tender and reaches at least 75°C inside. If it is still firm, add 100 ml water, cover and cook on low heat 15 minutes more, then reduce again.
Brush the grate or pan lightly with oil. Thread the tender strips carefully onto skewers in loose folds, leaving small gaps. Grill for 3 to 4 minutes on one side until the edges are browned and lightly charred, brushing with a little oil or ghee.
Turn and grill the other side for 3 to 4 minutes until charred at the edges and steaming hot. Repeat with the remaining skewers in batches if the grill is small. Use clean tongs and a clean plate for the cooked meat.
For a smoky flavour, slide the boti off the skewers into a clean heavy pot and set a small steel bowl in the middle. Heat the charcoal on the flame until red hot, carefully set it in the bowl with tongs and drizzle with 1 teaspoon ghee. Cover at once and leave for 3 minutes. Do this in a well-ventilated space and keep the pot away from children.
Remove the bowl and charcoal with tongs and let the boti rest for 2 minutes. Sprinkle with chaat masala and serve hot with lemon wedges and sliced onions.
Cooking tips
- Slice the beef across the grain while it is very cold, or after 20 minutes in the freezer, to get even thin strips.
- Use raw green papaya, not ripe papaya, and stick to the quantity given. Too much or too long a marinade turns the meat soft and mushy.
- Drain the yogurt well and reduce the masala until it clings, so the boti chars on the grill rather than steams.
- Never use the smoking step in a closed room. Charcoal gives off carbon monoxide, so keep the space well ventilated.
Substitutions
- Use boneless mutton or lamb leg instead of beef, and check for tenderness 10 to 15 minutes earlier, as it may cook faster.
- If you cannot find raw papaya, use 1 tsp of meat tenderiser powder made from papaya, or marinate for the full overnight time.
- Swap mustard oil for a neutral oil with an extra pinch of black pepper if you dislike its sharpness.
- Use besan (gram flour), dry roasted until fragrant, in place of roasted chickpea powder.
Serve with
Serve hot with warm paratha or naan, mint chutney, sliced raw onions, lemon wedges and a cool raita.
Storage
Keep cooked boti in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 2 days. Cool it within 2 hours of cooking. Raw marinated beef should stay chilled and be cooked within 12 hours.
Reheating
Warm in a hot pan with a teaspoon of oil and a splash of water for 3 to 4 minutes, turning often, until steaming hot all the way through. Avoid long reheating, which can dry the meat.
Nutrition per serving, estimated
Not shown for this recipe because it can’t be estimated reliably (for example, oil absorbed during deep frying varies a lot).
You might also cook
PakistaniMasala Omelette
The dhaba-style omelette: eggs beaten with onion, tomato, green chili and coriander, cooked thin and folded.
PakistaniBeef Nihari
Beef shank slow-cooked in a spiced gravy thickened with toasted flour. A weekend project that mostly cooks itself.
PakistaniPrawn Karahi
Juicy prawns tossed quickly in a tomato, ginger and green chilli masala until the oil glistens. A fast, punchy karahi that suits a weeknight dinner with hot naan.
PakistaniLahori Fried Fish
Crisp, golden pieces of white fish in a spiced gram flour coating, with ajwain, crushed coriander and lemon. It's a Lahore street-style dinner that comes together in under an hour.
Pakistani kitchen
PakistaniMutton Chops Masala (Pressure-Cooked Lamb Chops in Thick Onion-Yogurt Masala)
Mutton chops are marinated, pressure-cooked until soft, then finished in a thick, glossy masala that clings to the bone. A good Sunday dinner with naan or rice.
Tawa Naan (Soft Yogurt Naan Cooked on a Griddle)
Soft, bubbly naan made with yogurt and milk, cooked on a hot tawa or in the oven. A dependable flatbread for karahi, daal and kababs, no tandoor needed.
PakistaniChicken Corn Soup
A thick, gently peppery soup of shredded chicken, sweet corn and silky egg ribbons, in the style of Pakistani Chinese restaurants. Easy to make at home on a cold evening.
Kulcha (Oven-Baked Yogurt Bread with Nigella and Sesame)
Soft, fluffy round breads made with yogurt and milk, topped with nigella and sesame and brushed with butter. They bake in a hot home oven and go well with chanay, daal or any curry.